Call our lawyers
now
or,
have our lawyers
call you
Robert Hughes and Tendency Evidence
Updated on Jun 01, 2022 • 4 min read • 248 views • Copy Link
Robert Hughes and Tendency Evidence
News reports in the last couple of days indicate that Robert Hughes, former Australian actor best known for his role in ‘Hey Dad’, has lodged an appeal to the High Court against his conviction and sentence for multiple child sex offences spanning two decades.
Grounds for Appeal – Sentence
The appeal against his sentence is based on his claim that the adverse treatment he has received in prison makes his sentence more severe than is warranted and thus should be cut short. He has, it seems, been subjected to abuse from other prisoners including having boiling water, or faeces and urine, thrown over him on a regular basis. The NSW Court of Appeal rejected this claim just prior to Christmas 2015 saying that the trial judge had taken the likelihood of this kind of treatment into account in sentencing.
Grounds for Appeal – Conviction
The conviction is being appealed on the basis of a rule of evidence which, he claims, the court applied incorrectly. ‘Tendency evidence’ (previously known as ‘propensity evidence’) is one of the many complex rules of evidence that is difficult to balance so that both the victim and the accused are treated fairly. It refers to evidence submitted by the prosecution that does not directly relate to the charges in question, but demonstrates a tendency towards the same kind of behaviour. It is then left to the jury (or judge in limited cases) to decide whether the evidence shows that, since the accused acted that way in the past, they more than likely acted the same way on the occasion in question.
‘Tendency evidence’ refers to evidence submitted by the prosecution that does not directly relate to the charges in question, but demonstrates a tendency towards the same kind of behaviour.
What does it mean?
At times, proof of a tendency towards a particular kind of behaviour is the only real evidence of an offence. This is especially so in sexual offence cases where the case turns on one person’s word against the other. The difficulty for the courts is in balancing the introduction of this kind of evidence so that the trial is fair and so that it does not unjustifiably prejudice the accused. Remember that one of our central tenets of the criminal law – one that is vital to our criminal justice system – is that everyone who comes before the courts is innocent until they are proven otherwise. Consequently, all accused persons must be treated as if they were innocent of all charges unless and until the court finds – beyond reasonable doubt – that they are in fact guilty.
Evidence that shows someone did something they should not have done some time in the past does not necessarily mean that they acted the same way on the occasion in question. It is undeniable that people are capable of changing their behaviour. We all do things we should not do (though not all of it is criminal) – some of us learn from it and mend our ways; others continue on with the poor behaviour. The trick is in figuring out in which category the accused fits.
One of the ways the courts do this is to require that the tendency evidence be so significant to the case that its significance outweighs any prejudice to the accused. Robert Hughes will be arguing in the High Court that this was not the case for him. He will claim that the introduction of tendency evidence unfairly prejudiced his case and should not have been allowed. The NSW Court of Appeal rejected his argument, but it remains to be seen what position the High Court will take.
Laura Turner
Senior Associate
Laura Turner holds a Bachelor of Laws and Bachelor of Arts as well as a Graduate Diploma of Legal Practice. She is admitted to practice in the Supreme Court of Queensland. Laura began her legal experience through volunteering with the Student Legal Service offering free advice to students, and through a clerkship in the conveyancing team of a law firm in Hobart. She also volunteered at a Prisoner Legal Service, assisting inmates to obtain parole. Laura has a strong focus on family law, criminal and traffic law, although looks to broaden her knowledge into migration and civil law.
Affordable Lawyers
Our Go To Court Lawyers will assist you in all areas of law. We specialise in providing legal advice urgently – at the time when you need it most. If you need a lawyer right now, today, we can help you – no matter where you are in Australia.How It Works
1. You speak directly to a lawyer
When you call the Go To Court Legal Hotline, you will be connected directly to a lawyer, every time.
2. Get your legal situation assessed
We determine the best way forward in your legal matter, free of charge. If you want to go ahead and book a face-to-face appointment, we will connect you with a specialist in your local area.
3. We arrange everything as needed
If you want to go ahead and book a fact-to-face appointment, we will connect you with a specialist in your local area no matter where you are and even at very short notice.
Related Law Topics
Relaxing of COVID-19 Restrictions (Qld)
On 29 January 2020 the Health Minister declared a public health emergency in respect of the whole of the state of Queensland. Queensland passed a number of public health directions that imposed strict restrictions on the freedoms of individuals, including limiting the size of public gatherings and the reasons people could ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Stay at Home – What Does it Really Mean? (Vic)
During the COVID-19 pandemic, both the Federal and the Victorian governments have been implementing ever-changing rules. On 2 April 2020 the Stay at Home directives came into force. They were in force until the 11th May 2020. Please note the restrictions outlined below are no longer in force. What is an ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Strip Searches of Minors (NSW)
Concerns are being raised about the legality and appropriateness of strip searches carried out on minors by New South Wales police. The issue has come to light after Redfern Legal Centre obtained data on strip searches conducted in the last three years, revealing that there were 122 strip searches of ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Criminal Law
New South Wales
Officials Perverting the Course of Justice (NSW)
While police and judicial officers are responsible for prosecuting and sentencing individuals for criminal offences, sometimes people in positions of authority are themselves charged with perverting the course of justice. This commonly arises in circumstances that amount to an abuse of power. A recent case from the NSW Court of ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
New South Wales
Rape and the Defence of Honest Mistake (Qld)
The operation of Queensland laws around sexual assaults has come under scrutiny in recent months, with calls emerging for the state to be brought into line with other Australian jurisdictions by abolishing the defence of honest mistake. Queensland lawyer and author and Bri Lee, whose memoir Eggshell Skull documents her ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Enquiry Into Wage Theft Underway (Qld)
A Queensland parliamentary inquiry is investigating the problem of wage theft in Queensland. The committee will be looking at the incidence of wage theft in the state, its impact on workers, families, businesses, the community and the economy. It will consider why wage theft is occurring, which industries or occupations ....
Posted in:
Civil Law
Court Lawyers
Queensland
Following the deaths of seven in a mass shooting near Margaret River last week, criticisms have emerged of Australian gun laws. Whilst Australia has historically had a reputation as a leader in effective gun control, this tragedy has raised questions as to whether we are doing enough to ensure the ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Venture Capital: Is it The Way To Go?
Australia’s start-up scene is one of the most promising and rapidly progressing in the world. With the thirteenth largest economy and the ninth highest income per capita, Australia is fast beginning to project a Silicon Valley-esque sense of opportunity for start-ups. Venture capital is one way for aspiring founders to ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
New Rules for Drivers Overtaking Cyclists in WA
New minimum passing rules for drivers overtaking cyclists in Western Australia are to be introduced as a partial modification of the state’s Road Traffic Code. The new regulations are due to take effect in Western Australia as part of the state’s traffic law from the 30th of November 2017. New minimum passing rules ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Traffic Law
Western Australia
New George Street Office Gives Go To Court Clients More
National law firm Go To Court Lawyers is pleased to announce the opening of a new Brisbane CBD office on George Street. Located at 452 – 456 George Street, Brisbane, this office is situated directly across from the Queen Elizabeth II Courts of Law and the Roma Street Transit Centre. ....
Posted in:
Court Lawyers
Press Releases
Cannabis Legalised in Queensland for Medicinal Purposes
The Queensland Parliament has passed the Public Health (Medicinal Cannabis) Bill 2016. What this means is that from March 2017, the proposed laws will allow certain medical professionals to prescribe medicinal cannabis. The Bill was passed unanimously and aims to regulate cannabis for medicinal use through prescription. Cannabis products under ....
Posted in:
Blog
Court Lawyers
Criminal Law
Queensland
Thank You Tricia Habjan and Simi Ahuja for Your Dedication
17 October 2016 marks National Manager – Admin and Accounts, Tricia Habjan’s fifth year at Go To Court Lawyers and on 14 October 2016 Simi Ahuja celebrated two years at the firm. These two team members are part of Go To Court’s inspirational family of dedicated and hardworking individuals. Tricia ....
Posted in:
Blog
Court Lawyers