Private Prosecutions (Qld)

This article was prepared by Go To Court Lawyers, Australia's largest legal service. For legal advice specific to your situation, call 1300 636 846.

A private prosecution is a prosecution where the victim of an offence, rather than the state, prosecutes the alleged offender. In Queensland, private prosecutions can be initiated by natural persons or by corporations under the provisions of the Criminal Code Act 1995 and the Justices Act 1886.

Private prosecutions usually occur when the police have chosen not to prosecute an alleged offender after receiving a complaint. This legal avenue provides individuals with an important alternative when they believe justice has not been pursued through traditional channels. The right to bring private prosecutions is a fundamental aspect of Queensland's criminal justice system, ensuring that victims maintain some control over seeking justice for wrongs committed against them.

A private prosecution can occur in relation to any criminal offence. This includes summary offences (offences heard in the Magistrates Court) and indictable offences (offences heard in the higher courts). However, the complexity and requirements differ significantly between these two categories of offences.

Successful Private Prosecutions

In February 2020, the Guardian Australia reported that a Queensland woman had successfully prosecuted her former partner for serious domestic violence offences in a private prosecution. The victim took the unusual step of commencing a private prosecution after police refused to press charges against the man. This case highlighted the importance of private prosecutions in domestic violence matters where traditional prosecution pathways may fail victims.

In 2011, a homeless man successfully ran a private prosecution against the police for assaulting him at a public toilet in Brisbane. The man was originally found guilty of obstructing police and disobeying a lawful direction when he failed to leave the toilet when told to do so. On appeal, this decision was reversed and he subsequently initiated a private prosecution, demonstrating that private prosecutions can be brought against any person, including police officers.

These cases illustrate that private prosecutions, while uncommon, can be effective tools for securing justice when other avenues have been exhausted. They also demonstrate the courts' willingness to consider private prosecutions on their merits, regardless of the social status of the parties involved.

Procedure

Summary Offences Procedure

A private prosecution for a summary offence is commenced by the complainant filing a private complaint in the Magistrates Court under Section 42 of the Justices Act 1886. This must be served on the defendant with a summons requiring their attendance at court on the day the matter is listed. The complaint must be made within the statutory time limit, which is generally one year from when the offence was committed, unless otherwise specified.

Indictable Offences Procedure

Private prosecutions for indictable offences require leave from the Supreme Court under Section 686 of the Criminal Code. If leave is granted, the complainant must present an ex officio indictment as per the process set out in Section 686 of the Criminal Code 1899. The prosecution then proceeds by the same rules as if it had been commenced by the Crown. The application for leave must demonstrate that there are reasonable grounds for the prosecution and that it is in the public interest.

Preparing a Complaint or Indictment

Essential Elements

The complaint must be made in the prescribed form and must include all the necessary information. If a complaint is filed that does not include all the information that is required, it will be invalid and may be struck out by the court before proceedings commence.

A complaint alleging a summary offence must include:

• An adequate description of the alleged offence, referencing the specific section of the relevant Act
• The time, place and manner of the alleged act with sufficient precision
• Details of the particular act or thing alleged as forming the basis of the charge
• The full name and address of the defendant if known

Evidence Requirements

The complaint must be supported by sufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case. This means there must be enough evidence that, if accepted, would prove each element of the offence beyond reasonable doubt. If the court considers a complaint to be frivolous or vexatious or an abuse of process, it may strike it out under its inherent jurisdiction to prevent misuse of court processes.

When to Consider Private Prosecution

Circumstances for Private Prosecution

Private prosecutions should be considered when the Director of Public Prosecutions or police have declined to prosecute, but the complainant believes there is sufficient evidence and public interest in proceeding. Common situations include minor assaults, property damage, harassment cases, and certain white-collar crimes where victims have suffered financial loss.

Before commencing a private prosecution, complainants should carefully consider whether they have sufficient evidence, the likelihood of success, the costs involved, and whether the matter truly warrants criminal prosecution rather than civil action.

Alternatives to Consider

Before pursuing private prosecution, individuals should consider alternative dispute resolution methods, civil claims for damages, or requesting a review of the decision not to prosecute. Sometimes a fresh complaint to police with additional evidence may result in official charges being laid.

Role of the Director of Public Prosecutions

The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) maintains oversight of private prosecutions and has the power to intervene in or take over any private prosecution at any stage. Under Section 11 of the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1984, the DPP may discontinue a private prosecution if it is not in the public interest or take it over if it raises matters of public concern.

This oversight ensures that private prosecutions do not undermine the broader administration of justice or pursue matters that are contrary to prosecutorial guidelines or public policy.

Representation

A person bringing a private prosecution can hire a lawyer to represent them or they can represent themselves. Given the complexity of criminal law and court procedures, legal representation is strongly recommended. The defendant can also instruct a lawyer or choose to represent themselves.

Self-represented litigants in private prosecutions face significant challenges in faqs: - question: 'Can corporations initiate private prosecutions in Queensland?' answer: 'Yes, corporations can initiate private prosecutions in Queensland under the Criminal Code Act 1995 and the Justices Act 1886. Like natural persons, corporations have the legal right to commence private prosecutions when they are victims of criminal offences and traditional prosecution channels have not been pursued, providing an important alternative avenue for corporate entities seeking justice.' - question: 'What types of criminal offences can be prosecuted privately in Queensland?' answer: 'Private prosecutions in Queensland can be commenced for any criminal offence, including both summary offences heard in the Magistrates Court and indictable offences heard in higher courts. However, the complexity and legal requirements differ significantly between these categories, with indictable offences requiring more complex procedures and potentially involving committal proceedings and jury trials.' - question: 'How much does it cost to get legal advice about starting a private prosecution?' answer: 'Go To Court Lawyers offers a fixed $295 consultation fee to discuss private prosecution matters. During this consultation, you can receive expert legal advice about the viability of your case, the evidence required, potential costs involved, and the procedural requirements. This initial investment can help you understand whether a private prosecution is the right option for your circumstances.' - question: 'How can a criminal lawyer help with a private prosecution case?' answer: 'A criminal lawyer can assess the strength of your evidence, guide you through complex procedural requirements, prepare and file necessary court documents, represent you during hearings, and develop effective prosecution strategies. They can also advise on potential costs, risks, and alternatives, ensuring your private prosecution meets all legal standards and procedural requirements under Queensland law.' - question: 'Are there time limits for commencing a private prosecution in Queensland?' answer: 'Yes, there are strict time limits for commencing private prosecutions in Queensland that vary depending on the type of offence. Summary offences typically have shorter limitation periods, while indictable offences may have different timeframes. Acting quickly is crucial as delays can bar your right to prosecute, so seeking immediate legal advice is essential to preserve your options.' ---