Restraint of Trade in the ACT
Restraint of Trade in the ACT
Restraint of trade clauses are clauses that restrain a party to a contract from engaging in activities in commercial competition with the other party. Restraint of trade clauses are valid only where they are reasonable in the interests of the parties and in the interests of the public. This page deals with restraint of trade clauses in relation to employment law in the ACT.
Legislation
The ACT does not have any legislation on restraint of trade clauses. Restraint of trade is therefore governed by common law.
Where do restraint of trade clauses appear?
Restraint of trade clauses typically appear in:
- contracts for the sale of a business
- employment contracts
Where a restraint of trade clause appears in an employment contract it is generally intended to have effect after the employment relationship has terminated. Examples of behaviours that an employee or former employee may be restrained from are:
- using confidential information belonging to the employer
- starting a business that is in direct competition with the employer
- starting employment with a company that is a competitor of the employer
Legitimate business interests
Under the common law, restraint of trade clauses have historically been presumed to be invalid or void for public policy reasons. This was because they are designed to restrict a party’s ability to trade or to be gainfully employed. However, over time, restraint of trade clauses have become more entrenched in employment contracts.
Courts have found restraint of trade clauses to be valid so long as:
- they are designed to protect the employer’s ‘legitimate business interests’; and
- they do no more than is reasonable for the protection of those interests.
What is reasonable in protecting a legitimate business interest will depend on a number of considerations including:
- the nature of the business activity of the firm and the trade, skill or profession that the employee possesses or to which the employee belongs;
- the geographical restraint area stipulated under the clause and whether it is reasonable to extend it as far as the contract does;
- the duration of the restraint;
- the extent of the employee’s involvement in procuring clients and maintaining business relationships.
Cascading restraints
To get around the uncertainty of what exactly is reasonable in the protection of its legitimate business interests, an employer may write what is known as a ‘cascading restraint clause’ into a contract.
A cascading restraint clause is a clause that is written in such a way that there is more than one option in terms of the ambit of what a party is restrained from doing or for how long they are restrained from doing it.
While a restraint of trade clause will be struck out if a court finds it to be unreasonable and therefore invalid, a cascading restraint clause will be struck out only to the extent that it is unreasonable, with the remainder of the clause remaining enforceable.
For example, a cascading restraint clause may provide that an employee is retrained from starting a business that is in competition with the employer for:
- 12 months after ceasing employment with the company;
- Two years after ceasing employment with the company;
- Five years after ceasing employment with the company.
A court considering the contract can then strike out the options that are unreasonable and uphold the one that is reasonable.
Wording of restraint of trade clauses
The precise scope of a restraint of trade clause is often determined by the way the clause is drafted. For example, a clause may stipulate that an employee may not ‘solicit’, ‘canvas’ or ‘secure’ clients or former clients of the employer.
While the word ‘solicit’ has a generally accepted meaning of actively going out to attract clients, ‘secure’ has a much broader scope and includes actions that resulted from the initiative of the customer/client.
When reviewing restraint of trade clauses in employment contracts or sale of business contracts, you should always consult a lawyer to determine the scope of the clause.
Relief for breaches of a restraint of trade clause
If an employer or a seller suspects an employee or purchaser of breaching a restraint of trade clause, they may seek relief by way of an injunction to prevent the breach from continuing.
A party may also also seek compensation for a loss of profits resulting from a breach.
To seek either of these forms of relief in the ACT, a party must commence proceedings in the Supreme Court of the ACT. The application must be supported by evidence that the clause was breached and evidence of the losses the party suffered as a result.
If you require legal advice or representation in any legal matter, please contact Go To Court Lawyers.
Michelle Makela
National Practice Manager
Michelle Makela is a Legal Practice Director at Go To Court Lawyers. She holds a Juris Doctor, a Bachelor of Science (Psychology) and a Master of Criminology. She was admitted to practice in 2006. Michelle has over 15 years experience in the legal industry, working across commercial litigation, criminal law, family law and estate planning.
Affordable Lawyers
Our Go To Court Lawyers will assist you in all areas of law. We specialise in providing legal advice urgently – at the time when you need it most. If you need a lawyer right now, today, we can help you – no matter where you are in Australia.How It Works
1. You speak directly to a lawyer
When you call the Go To Court Legal Hotline, you will be connected directly to a lawyer, every time.
2. Get your legal situation assessed
We determine the best way forward in your legal matter, free of charge. If you want to go ahead and book a face-to-face appointment, we will connect you with a specialist in your local area.
3. We arrange everything as needed
If you want to go ahead and book a fact-to-face appointment, we will connect you with a specialist in your local area no matter where you are and even at very short notice.
Related Law Topics
Reproductive Leave Reproductive leave is a new form of workplace entitlement. Reproductive leave provides paid time off for health issues such as menstruation, IVF, perimenopause, menopause, vasectomies, hysterectomy, terminations and gender transition treatments. While reproductive leave is currently only available in a few workplaces in Australia, unions are working to ....
Posted in:
Employment
Performance Management of Employees
Performance Management of Employees Australia has strict laws around the performance management of employees. Employers need to be aware of workplace protections and adopt a policy for performance management that is both fair to employees and compliant with Australian law. This article looks at the legal implications of employee performance ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Grievances When an employee has a workplace grievance, they can approach their employer informally, or refer the issue to the Fair Work Commission or to a state or territory workplace health and safety authority. Most companies in Australia also offer an avenue for employees to make a formal complaint ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Restructuring Workplace restructuring is the deliberate reorganisation of a business’s operations or workforce. This process may include closing offices or retail locations, merging, combining, dividing, or eliminating entire departments, and altering employee roles and responsibilities. Australian employers planning to restructure the workplace must do so with an awareness of ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Discrimination in South Australia
In South Australia, the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 makes it unlawful to discriminate against a person on the basis of certain attributes including race, sex and disability. Discrimination is unlawful in the workplace, as well as in a number of other areas of public life. Some South Australian workers are also covered ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Discrimination in Queensland | Employment Lawyers QLD
Workplace discrimination refers to treating a person less favourably on the grounds of a certain attribute, such as race, sex, sexuality, political or religious belief, or sex work activity. The main legislation which prohibits discrimination in Queensland is the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, which makes discriminatory conduct unlawful, and therefore actionable at ....
Posted in:
Employment
Intellectual Property Created During Employment
Intellectual Property Created During Employment Intellectual property created during employment relates to employees creating products, documents, and materials which are copyrightable. These goods and products include things such as designs, blueprints, educational materials and web content. Under Australian copyright legislation, any material that is either classified as an ‘original work’ ....
Posted in:
Employment
Employment Law in New South Wales | Employment Lawyers NSW
Employment is regulated at both state and federal levels. In New South Wales, federal employment laws apply in some situations, while in others the state protections apply. This article deals with employment law in New South Wales, including anti-discrimination laws, unfair dismissal and minimum working conditions. State or federal law? ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Investigations In Australia, employers have a common law and statutory duty to provide a safe work environment and protect employees from discrimination and harassment. As part of this duty, employers sometimes conduct workplace investigations into a range of different issues, from worker disputes to allegations of employee misconduct. This ....
Posted in:
Employment
Workplace Health and Safety Workplace Health and Safety (WHS) is the process of protecting people from risk while they are at work, with the intent to prevent work-related accidents and injuries. In Australia, the Work Health & Safety Act 2011 mandates that all employees have a right to a healthy ....
Posted in:
Employment
Sexual Harassment (NT) Residents of the Northern Territory are protected from sexual harassment under both federal and Territory law. The Anti-Discrimination Act 1992 prohibits sexual harassment in the Northern Territory, and the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 criminalises the behaviour at a federal level. If a person experiences sexual harassment in ....
Posted in:
Employment
Working With Vulnerable People (NT)
Working With Vulnerable People (NT) A person who works with vulnerable people must be trustworthy. Vulnerable individuals are, by definition, less able to look after their own interests and are statistically more likely to be the victims of physical, sexual and financial abuse. Some states and territories in Australia have ....
Posted in:
Employment